With All Due Respect, I Don’t Want Your Peer Review

Karly

I have a rather controversial confession to make, particularly for someone who spent a considerable portion of her formative years studying languages, linguistics, literature, and the various ways in which human beings manage to make themselves understood, misunderstood, or unnecessarily complicated: I’m extraordinarily glad that I will probably never have to write for a strictly academic readership, and I say this with all the affection in the world for academia, which has given me some of my greatest intellectual pleasures and, occasionally, some of my most spectacular headaches.

This isn’t an announcement of my retirement from intellectual pursuits, nor is it an attempt to suggest that academic writing is inherently tedious, pretentious, or inaccessible, although I would argue that certain corners of academia have made accessibility considerably more difficult than it needs to be. Rather, it’s an acknowledgment that I’ve spent enough time in academic environments to know that, while I thoroughly enjoy researching, analysing, questioning, and occasionally obsessing over the smallest linguistic or literary detail, I don’t particularly enjoy the prospect of having every observation subjected to the intellectual equivalent of a courtroom cross-examination.

There is, after all, only so much yes, but have you considered… that one woman can reasonably tolerate before she begins to wonder whether expressing an opinion was worth the administrative burden of defending it, particularly when the original observation was never intended to constitute a groundbreaking contribution to the field.

I should probably clarify that I’m not opposed to criticism, intellectual disagreement, or the rather inconvenient possibility of being wrong, because all three are necessary components of serious scholarship and, indeed, of becoming a reasonably tolerable human being. What I do object to is the particular kind of scrutiny that seems less interested in engaging with an argument than in identifying the precise moment at which its author can be made to feel intellectually inadequate, especially when the criticism is delivered with the air of someone who has just discovered a fatal flaw in the foundations of Western civilisation.

Anyone who has spent time in academia will probably recognise the phenomenon, although experiences naturally differ between institutions, disciplines, and individual academics, and I would hate to commit the very generalisation for which someone might otherwise feel compelled to correct me. You make an observation, perhaps one that is perfectly reasonable within the context of your argument, only to be informed that it requires further qualification, additional theoretical framing, or a more explicit acknowledgment of a scholar whose work was published approximately forty-seven years before you were born. Before long, the original observation has become so thoroughly surrounded by qualifications that you can barely remember what you were trying to say in the first place.

Sometimes, of course, those qualifications genuinely improve the argument, and I would be doing academic scholarship an enormous disservice if I pretended otherwise, but I also think it’s possible to become so preoccupied with anticipating objections that writing ceases to feel like a process of communicating ideas and begins to resemble an elaborate exercise in self-defence.

I say this as someone who has, in fact, been told that she couldn’t write, which is a rather remarkable thing to tell a person whose education has involved producing an extraordinary amount of written work and who has subsequently chosen to spend a considerable amount of her adult life doing precisely that.

One might reasonably argue that a particular piece of writing is unsuccessful, that its argument lacks coherence, that its structure needs improvement, or that its author has misunderstood the material, and I would consider all of these legitimate criticisms provided that they are accompanied by something resembling constructive feedback. Declaring that someone simply cannot write, however, is an entirely different proposition, because it transforms an assessment of a particular piece of work into a sweeping judgment about the author’s abilities, as though writing were an immutable personal characteristic rather than a skill that develops through practice, reading, revision, and experience.

The irony, naturally, is that I now write for a living, or at least spend enough of my professional life writing, editing, and conducting literary research that the distinction seems increasingly unimportant, and I have discovered that not being subjected to academic evaluation has done remarkably little to diminish my interest in intellectual work. If anything, it has made that work more enjoyable.

When we established Nonsense & Lit, one of the things that appealed to me most was the possibility of creating a space in which literary criticism, linguistic analysis, cultural commentary, and the occasional profoundly unserious observation could coexist without requiring permission from an academic department. I could write about pragmatics one week, examine a literary adaptation the next, and subsequently devote an unreasonable amount of attention to a fictional character’s conversational habits, all while drawing upon the theoretical frameworks that had fascinated me throughout my education.

The difference was that I no longer needed to pretend that intellectual curiosity had to conform to the boundaries of a single discipline, nor did I have to justify why something was worth discussing simply because it happened to belong to popular culture rather than to an established literary canon.

I find it particularly strange that accessibility is occasionally treated as though it were the enemy of intellectual sophistication, because surely the ability to explain a complicated concept to someone who has never encountered it before is evidence of understanding rather than its absence. There is considerable skill involved in making linguistic theory relevant to an everyday conversation, or in discussing literary criticism without presuming that one’s readership has already completed several years of postgraduate study, and I would argue that such writing can demand just as much intellectual discipline as a more conventionally academic piece.

This isn’t to suggest that an essay published in an independent literary magazine performs the same function as a peer-reviewed research article, because the two are governed by different expectations and intended to accomplish different things. Academic scholarship requires methodological transparency, engagement with existing research, and a level of evidential scrutiny that is entirely appropriate to its purpose, whereas literary and cultural essays often have greater freedom to experiment with form, voice, interpretation, and the relationship between writer and reader.

What interests me is the assumption that one form of writing must necessarily be more intellectually valuable than the other, particularly when the most compelling ideas are not always those that can be expressed most comfortably within the conventions of academic publication.

I have no desire to abandon the things that my education taught me, and I suspect that even if I attempted to do so, I would find myself returning to discourse analysis, pragmatics, or some obscure grammatical distinction within approximately fifteen minutes. My academic background shapes the questions I ask, the connections I make, and the way I approach texts, even when those texts happen to be television scripts, contemporary novels, or exchanges between fictional people who are spectacularly incapable of communicating with one another.

What I don’t particularly want is to spend the rest of my life writing as though an examiner were permanently stationed over my shoulder, waiting to inform me that my argument might benefit from a more nuanced consideration of a theoretical position that I had not realised I was required to acknowledge.

There is something wonderfully liberating about being able to write a sentence because it communicates precisely what I mean, rather than because I have spent twenty minutes determining whether it is sufficiently defensible against every possible objection, and I have discovered that I rather enjoy allowing myself to be funny, opinionated, and occasionally exasperated without worrying that these qualities might undermine the seriousness of my work.

Naturally, intellectual freedom comes with responsibilities of its own, and publishing independently doesn’t absolve anyone of the obligation to research properly, represent sources accurately, or reconsider an argument when presented with convincing evidence to the contrary. I still care very much about getting things right, and I would be mortified to discover that I had confidently published something demonstrably false, but I no longer believe that the possibility of being corrected ought to determine whether I write something in the first place.

Perhaps that is the distinction I’ve been trying to articulate all along, because I don’t want a readership that agrees with everything I say, and I certainly don’t expect every interpretation I offer to be universally accepted. What I want is the freedom to participate in intellectual conversations without feeling as though every contribution constitutes an application for admission to a club whose members reserve the right to question whether I belong there.

And yes, I recognise that academic scrutiny can be an enormously productive form of intellectual exchange, that disagreement frequently leads to better scholarship, and that many academics are exceptionally generous readers who devote considerable time and energy to helping others improve their work. I’ve encountered enough of them to know that academia is not populated exclusively by people waiting to correct someone’s bibliography, and it would be both unfair and rather hypocritical to reduce an entire professional community to its least encouraging representatives.

Nevertheless, the fact that scrutiny can be valuable doesn’t mean that I particularly want to make a career out of being subjected to it, especially when I have discovered a way to engage with many of the same ideas in an environment that allows me to enjoy the process of writing rather than merely endure the process of having written.

I suppose there is something faintly amusing about spending years acquiring the intellectual tools associated with academic work, only to discover that my preferred use for them involves writing about whatever happens to interest me that week, but I don’t consider that education wasted simply because I have chosen not to pursue a conventional academic career.

On the contrary, I think one of the greatest privileges of having received that education is being able to carry its influence into spaces where its ideas might otherwise remain unfamiliar, and there is something profoundly satisfying about knowing that a reader can encounter a linguistic concept or literary theory through an essay that doesn’t require them to possess a university login or an encyclopaedic knowledge of the relevant scholarship.

I still love academia, and I expect that I always will, because my intellectual interests were shaped by people, books, classrooms, and conversations that encouraged me to think more carefully about language and literature than I might otherwise have done. I simply don’t believe that loving an intellectual environment obliges me to spend my professional life within it, any more than appreciating academic scholarship requires me to reproduce all of its conventions whenever I sit down to write.

Besides, having once been informed that I couldn’t write, I find a certain satisfaction in the fact that I now get to decide what to write, how to write it, and whom I hope will read it, without needing to convince anyone that I possess the necessary qualifications to put my thoughts into sentences.

And if someone still wishes to inform me that my argument lacks sufficient theoretical grounding, I would be delighted to consider their objections, although I reserve the right to continue writing exactly as I please.

Leave a Reply